Gaza Postmortems

by Stephen Lendman


Discussion ranges from who won, who lost, who cares, what’s next. Media scoundrels support Israeli aggression like they always do. More on that below.

Operation Pillar of Cloud, like decades of similar Israeli aggression, wasn’t about self-defense in response to Palestinian rockets or other incidents.

It reflects Israeli regional hegemonic ambitions, its culture of violence and belligerence, occupation harshness, land theft, Palestinian dispossession, institutionalized racism, and contempt for rule of law principles and democratic values.

Much more about Operation Pillar of Cloud is important. Washington wholeheartedly supports Israeli aggression. Close collaboration is policy.

Political cover is given. Billions of dollars in annual military aid is provided. Intelligence is shared. Joint military exercises are held. They’re strategically planned.

Michel Chossudovsky explained that one week after US elections “the largest joint war games in Israeli history” took place. Months of joint planning preceded them.

Their objective “was to test Israel’s missile air defense system against attacks from far and near, namely from Iran, Hezbollah and Hamas.”

Austere Challenge 12 joint military exercises “were conducted over four weeks overlapping with the US elections (November 6) and culminating with the commencement of the Gaza bombings (November 14).”

Operation Pillar of Cloud was planned months in advance. Selecting targets take considerable time. Tactics and overall strategy require careful decision-making.

Joint US/Israeli war games had a purpose. They were planned to precede “an actual military operation.”

Washington and Israel partner directly or indirectly in all regional wars and lesser-scale conflicts. The Pentagon maintains command and control operations in Israel.

Washington runs things. “With regard to the joint US-Israel war games which culminated with the attack on Gaza, Israel is visibly the junior partner.”

“The United States is not ‘supporting’ an Israeli military endeavor.” It’s a “major actor in the attack on Gaza. The US is therefore a perpetrator of war crimes together with Israel.”

Seldom are these important observations made. Imperial ambitions are involved. Large and smaller military operations have a purpose.

Expect others to follow Operation Pillar of Cloud. Cessation of current hostilities is a ruse. Israel and Washington will invent pretexts to continue conflict. False flags will be used. So will manufactured provocations.

Hamas, other resistance groups, and regional independent governments will be blamed. The same scheme plays out in disturbing repetition. This time won’t be different.

On November 21, each side claimed victory. As they say, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. It’s toxic.

Netanyahu claimed Israel “destroyed Hamas’ control over the Strip.”

Barak said “all the operation’s aims were fulfilled.”

Hamas political head Khaled Meshal said Israel’s “attack failed and the leaders of the enemy failed in their adventure.”

“Eight days of fighting forced them to give in to our conditions. The destruction left by Israel did nothing to change the fact that the resistance won.”

After 64 years, Palestinians haven’t achieved a single meaningful victory. At the same time, anti-Israel/US sentiment grows.

Global protests condemned Cast Lead. They erupted again after Pillar of Cloud attacks. Hundreds of protests occurred throughout the Middle East, Europe, North America, and elsewhere.

Israel and perhaps America are the world’s most reviled countries. Growing millions reject their contempt for human life and well-being.

Debate continues over military and political winners. Palestinian resistance is no match against Israel’s war machine. The death, injury, and destruction toll on both sides leaves no ambiguity.

Politically it’s different. Pro-Palestinian sentiment grows. So does anti-Israeli hostility. An earlier article asked if Israel overstepped this time. World protests suggest perhaps so if only modestly. What follows remains to be seen.

Another article said peace isn’t won on battlefields. It’s when dialogue replaces belligerence. Conflicts beget more of them. Endless violence is self-destructive.

Long-term, no one wins. Peace and stability depend on prioritizing diplomacy over confrontation. Regional conditions are deteriorating. Something has to give.

Belligerence doesn’t work. One analyst suggested the obvious. Why not give peace a chance. Imagine the possibilities not so far considered.

Ceasefire terms leave much to be desired. Fundamental injustices weren’t resolved. Provisions and language leave disturbing wiggle room. Memorandum of understanding terms include:

(1) Israel to cease air, land, and sea hostilities, as well as stop targeted killings.

(2) Palestinian resistance groups to halt rocket and other attacks.

(3) Easing blockade restrictions modestly. Not enough to matter. Gaza’s siege continues. Free movement remains restricted.

Implementation procedures not yet decided. Negotiations will determine them.

Oslo left major unresolved issues for later final status talks. They included borders, Palestinian sovereignty, the right of return, settlements, and East Jerusalem as Palestine’s capital among others.

Over 19 years later, no progress whatever was made on these and other important issues. This time won’t be different.

(4) Cessation of hostilities took effect at 2PM EST (9PM regional time).

(5) Egypt to act as guarantor. “Egypt shall receive assurances from each party that the party commits to what was agreed upon.”

(6) “Each party shall commit itself not to perform any acts that would breach this understanding. In case of any observations Egypt as the sponsor of this understanding shall be informed to follow up.”

Netanyahu provisionally agreed to halt hostilities. He reserved the right to resume them any time for any reason or none at all.

Agreed on terms resembled what followed Cast Lead. Washington was guarantor. The fox guarded the hen house. It still does. Conflict continued. Nothing this time is different.

Deals don’t reflect or determine long-term policy. Nothing will change until Israel and Washington are held fully accountable. They’re responsible for decades of crimes of war and against humanity.

Day of reckoning time is nowhere in sight. Resolution won’t happen until it arrives.

Haaretz discussed “behind the scenes” (decision-making to) “accept Gaza truce.” Top ministers disagreed. Barak wanted conflict ended. “Lieberman demanded a ground invasion.” Netanyahu “vacillated.”

Discussions continued for days. They and other hardliners thought Egypt “align(ed) with Hamas and tr(ied) to provide it with achievements.”

Barak set the record straight. Ceasefire wording means nothing, he said.

“Israel’s power of deterrence would be tested by the reality on the ground.”

“A day after the cease-fire, no one will remember what is written in that draft. The only thing that will be tested is the blow Hamas suffered.”

“We can put off the Egyptian proposal and go for a precarious ground incursion of Gaza, but at the end of the day, we may end up with the same exact result.”

Haaretz editors headlined “It’s all connected.” They side with Israel’s war machine. They know better but don’t show it. They support what they should condemn.

Palestinian self-defense is called “terrorism.” They urge Gaza residents to “get rid of the Hamas government.” At the same time, they know it long ago proved “unrealistic.”

Separate West Bank and Gaza authority doesn’t “guarantee quiet and stability, or surrender and political obedience from the Palestinians.”

To its credit, Haaretz advocates diplomacy and peace over force. At the same time, vital issues are ignored.

Hamas is Palestine’s legitimate government. It’s not a terrorist organization. Nor is Islamic Jihad, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, or other resistance groups. Palestinian sovereignty exists. Israel’s occupation is illegal.

It bears full responsibility for aggressive wars. It’s guilty of crimes of war and against humanity that follow. They’re longstanding. They’ve been ongoing since before 1948.

Palestinians are human beings. Their rights matter as much as Jewish ones. Israel denies them. Conflict will persist until that ends.

There’s no ambiguity. Abused people react. Brutalized ones defend themselves aggressively. It’s their right under international law.

Until long denied justice is achieved, confrontation and violence will continue. It’s not unique to the region. It’s the same everywhere.

Media scoundrels don’t notice or care. On November 21, a New York Times editorial headlined “A New Israel-Hamas Cease-Fire,” saying:

Peace won’t follow without “serious” “two-state solution” discussions. Years ago it was possible. No longer. A previous article explained.

Israel controls over half the West Bank and much of East Jerusalem. More is added daily.

When completed, the apartheid wall will control over 10% of Palestine. Isolated ghettoized bantustans on worthless scrubland won’t work. Under those conditions, sovereign viability is impossible.

The only solution is one state comprised of Israel and the Territories. Nothing else will work.

The Times admitted that ceasefire terms leave much to be desired. Netanyahu “left open the possibility of ‘more severe military action’ ” based on any pretext he claims.

How longstanding Palestinian grievances will be addressed remains “unclear.” In fact, they’ll be ignored like always.

The Times disgracefully calls Hamas a “terrorist organization.” It rejects its legitimacy. It praised Obama’s role in the conflict. It ignored US complicity with Israel in initiating it.

Belligerents always plan new campaigns. Expect the worst ahead in 2013. Point fingers the right way. Washington, Israel, and key NATO partners bear full responsibility. Don’t expect scoundrel media editors to explain.

About the Author: Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at

His new book is titled “How Wall Street Fleeces America: Privatized Banking, Government Collusion and Class War”

Visit his blog site at and listen to cutting-edge discussions with distinguished guests on the Progressive Radio News Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays at 10AM US Central time and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs are archived for easy listening.

Bookmark and Share

Short URL:

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VT or any other VT authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors, partners and technicians. Legal Notice

Posted by on Nov 23 2012, With 0 Reads, Filed under Israel, Middle East, Palestine. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.


To post, we ask that you login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with VT and post.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Feedback

Comments Closed

6 Comments for “Gaza Postmortems”

  1. Michel Chossudovsky??? Lendman, are you kidding? That twerp is just like Alex Jones: happy to talk about everything and anything except how rabid Israeli Jewish supremacists and their Fifth Column agents in the USA are the true Global Enemy No. 1.

    Disinformation agents constantly attempt to blame the “American Empire” and “Anglo-American bankers” rather than finger the Real Terrorists: the Jewish supremacist overlords that own those guys like pets on a leash. Webster Tarpley is another one, he’s made a career of doing this.

    Take a look at this typical Chossudovsky misdirection line:

    “Washington runs things. “With regard to the joint US-Israel war games which culminated with the attack on Gaza, Israel is visibly the junior partner.”

    Wtf? “Washington” doesn’t “run” jack shit. Is Chossudovsky this stupid, or did he just prove who his employer is? That he would go out of his way to write such drivel and attempt to position things this way is a dead giveaway. The man is either too stupid or too evil to be listened to or to be taken seriously. Yet his quotes are what Lendman builds on. It’s a waste of good VT space: simply a case of garbage in, garbage out.

    Shame on you Stephen Lendman. Continue to use Chossudovsky as a “source” and attempt to obscure the real chain of command at the peril of your credibility. Most VT readers see right through these tired, overused attempts at misdirection. If you can’t square up with the facts on the ground, handle the heat, and name the true enemy of mankind, then get the hell out of the kitchen. Stop trying to feed us lies and propaganda. Or go write for “Infowars”, you’ll fit right in.

  2. Never forget that unlike the US, the Israelis actually choose their government and know what its policies are, which makes them complicit in the war crimes – maybe a unique situation in history.

  3. Warlord Moneybags

    Is the US a willing player or is it just that it is under the Zionist thumb ?

    If so, is the present US government a willing player or is it just that it is under the US oligarchy’s thumb ?

    Are there any good guys left, or are we on our own ?

  4. Franklin Ryckaert

    Stephen Lendman is right : nothing has been achieved, nothing has changed. Nothing will probably change in the forseeable future, untill the next crisis happens and so on.

    • Until Obama et al get caught in another gun running scheme and can use the isrealis
      (or whomever) as guninee pigs for the empire. Etc. etc.

  5. These are different creatures. They can NOT be dealt with rationally. Their ideology comes from a lunatic asylum located in hell! One look at the average zionist drone tells the story.

Comments are closed


Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE


  1. US aid worker beheading video a set-up?
  2. At-risk veterans need help on suicide, senators say
  3. VetLikeMe Weekly 11/20/2014
  4. NEO – US-Armed Syrian Opposition “Surrenders” to Al Qaeda?
  5. All Wars are Bankers’ Wars
  6. Part 1. The Battle of the Bulge and the Malmedy Massacre
  7. GOP Immigration Con: “Sweatshop America”
  8. Murder in Jerusalem
  9. Dr. Ismail Salami – UN resolution on Iran mockery of justice
  10. Kiev Plans Full-Scale War
  11. Minor Anomaly Threatens
  12. MKO, Driving Force Behind Anti-Iran UN Resolution
  13. Pilger and Assange, Theatre of the Absurd (redux)
  14. NEO – US-backed Regime Change in Georgia
  15. What passes for Justice in New York today: The case of Sean Dix
  16. Kerry tells Lavrov to ignore Obama’s Russian threat comment
  17. M.A.S.H. helps homeless veterans find housing
  18. US lied about 9/11 attacks to justify waging wars: Analyst
  19. RT: Sub Off Sweden May be Dutch
  20. Russia Today on Urals “Event”
  1. DGSE: Hi Ahab Since you asked, I am still trying to find out what "Nazism" REALLY is/means! I was "conditioned" in the West, in a country totally controlled by the zio, so ...
  2. Emma Yacht: Finally... "Praise be to god." Onlookers know when it is 12 midnight ( in, past the 11th hour, and 'when the new day launches') because then the boy children finally ...
  3. workingactor: Probably a hoax..but it occurred to me yesterday, Gordon, do you know any legit remote-viewers? A good one could actually "take a look" and see if there's actually something there. ...
  4. drbhelthi: How many foreign countries have been colonized by Iran ? Cuba and Russia seem to be the only countries with which the effort by the CIA/MOSSAD to colonize has failed. It ...
  5. sweetliberty: Please

Veterans Today Poll

For over 60 years, US Taxpayers have been funding Israel, Palestine and Middle East. Are you happy with return on investment or would you prefer those monies be invested at home instead?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...