JOIN TEAM VT | SIGN UP DAILY NEWSLETTER
VETERANS TODAY ON : FACEBOOK | TWITTER | VT FORUM
|

Saving Philadelphia Schools Through Tax Reform

Philadelphia student union

Adopting a Land Value Tax Like Pittsburgh

 

By Dr Stuart Jeanne Bramhall

 

I have been extremely impressed to see Philadelphia’s students, teachers, parents and churches organizing at the grassroots level. Their demand? That Republican governor Tom Corbett restore $629 million he cut from the school district budget (to transfer to privately run charter schools). However given the massive amount of debt the city and school district are incurring to keep public schools open, I can’t help but think Parents United For Public Education, the Philadelphia Student Union, and other clergy and activist groups might be making the wrong demand. The track record of other states in forcing governors to backtrack on austerity cuts and school privatization is extremely poor. Thus I think it makes more sense for Philadelphia’s growing school reform movement to demand changes they can achieve – namely tax reform that shifts the tax burden from small business and low and middle income residents to the banks, real estate developers, and land speculators who own the bulk of the city’s real estate.

Until a week ago, it was unclear whether Philadelphia’s public schools would even open this fall. According to the corporate media, they have been “saved” at the last minute by a $50 bailout from the city of Philadelphia, money the city will borrow on the “financial markets” (i.e. Goldman Sachs). This debt is on top of a $300 million bond the school district floated last year, adding substantially to the district’s $280 million in annual debt payments. Despite all this borrowing – and closing 23 schools in April – on September 9 students will have school buildings to go to, but no administrators, school secretaries, counselors, librarians, textbooks, school nurses, paper, or pens. Moreover, at least one school is asking parents to front up with $613 per student

The Debt Trap

This cycle of continuous borrowing is a trap a lot of cities fall into owing to the gross unfairness of municipal tax structures. Philadelphia’s local taxes include a city income tax, sales tax, and business and occupation tax. This is on top of a property tax weighted towards land improvements. All tax low income residents and small businesses more heavily than wealthy banks and real estate developers and speculators. The same is true of most US cities, which is the major reason they have incurred massive debt to maintain crumbling infrastructure and schools. This is a no-win situation, as debt repayment to banks and bondholders captures an ever bigger share of city and school budgets.

Pittsburgh’s Land Value Tax

Pittsburgh, in contrast, derives most of its municipal funding from a Land Value Tax. Pittsburgh’s LVT taxes the value of unimproved land at five times the rate of homes and business operations built on that that land.

The concept of Land Value Tax – of taxing real estate values rather than structural improvements – is very old. Adam Smith first proposed it in 1776 in the Wealth of Nations. San Francisco journalist Henry George became world famous in 1879 by expounding on Smith’s ideas in Progress and Poverty. This book, which should be required reading by every economics graduate, was deliberately suppressed in the US by J.D. Rockefeller, JP Morgan, Ezra Cornell, and the railroad barons who funded the major American universities. Contrary to popular misconception, America’s corporate elite derive the vast majority of their wealth from their monopolization of land and natural resources. According to Walter Rybeck in Re-Solving the Economic Puzzle, 95% of privately held land is owned by 3% of Americans.

The property tax structure in most cities rewards landowners to engage in real estate speculation and to keep land and foreclosed homes empty. It also rewards slumlords not to undertake upgrades and repairs in their tenements. This is because any land improvements result in a property tax increase.

Countries and Cities Which Have Adopted an LVT

George turned out to be much more famous overseas than in the US. Countries which adopted a variation of LVT (Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, Denmark and numerous jurisdictions in Australia and New Zealand) have all thrived – mainly owing to their ability to fund infrastructure maintenance and schools without incurring debt. Experience has been similar in US cities and regions which have implemented an LVT. These include California’s Central Valley, Fairhope Alabama, and Arden Delaware.

According to the Center for the Study of Economics, Pittsburgh, Harrisburg and 15 other Pennsylvania towns and cities presently employ a  type of LVT to fund city services.  Last year Montreal adopted a version of LVT by doubling the tax rate on parking lots. Other communities looking at adopting an LVT include New London, Connecticut, Lanesborough Massachusetts, and Portland Oregon.

For a great video explaining how Land Value Tax works to reduce debt, fund schools and infrastructure, and end real estate speculation and boom and bust cycles, check out the video Real Estate 4 Ransom:


YouTube - Veterans Today -

Bookmark and Share

Short URL: http://www.veteranstoday.com/?p=265469

The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VT or any other VT authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors, partners and technicians. Legal Notice

Posted by on Aug 24 2013, With 0 Reads, Filed under Economics & Markets, Economy. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

COMMENTS

To post, we ask that you login using Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail in the box below.
Don't have a social network account? Register and Login direct with VT and post.
Before you post, read our Comment Policy - Feedback

Comments Closed

2 Comments for “Saving Philadelphia Schools Through Tax Reform”

  1. This writer’s articles are unfailingly logical. This is another example of Bramhall’s problem-solving common sense.

    • Dr Bramhall is one of the most knowledgeable people on the internet but intelligence is not everything. The best thing about Dr Bramhall is that her agenda only includes the continuation of the human race minus the preconceived and petty notions of pride and prejudice that mar most peoples judgment.

Comments are closed

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Join Our Daily Newsletter
  View Newsletter ARCHIVE

WHAT'S HOT

  1. NEO – Organized Crime in the 21st Century
  2. Uri Avnery – Two Speeches
  3. Tiny Monsters, Human Devils & a Poison Park (Water Wars 2.0)
  4. Memo To Employers: Veterans Aren’t PTSD Basketcases; They’re Disciplined And Committed
  5. Libya in Free Fall
  6. Biden blames US allies for backing Jihadis
  7. UK PM declares 9/11 and 7/7 Truthers must be dealt with as harshly as ISIS
  8. NEO – The World gets smaller as ambitions grow
  9. US firepower surrounding Russia, China
  10. JBLM plans to give Vietnam Vets the homecoming they deserved 50 years ago
  11. VA Funds Will Help 70,000 Homeless Vets And Their Families
  12. Bijorhca – France’s Largest Int’l Trade Show for Fine Fashion, Jewelry and Watches
  13. They Expected Iran From The East – They Got Da’esh From The West
  14. Pro-Russians launch new attacks to seize Donetsk airport
  15. Ukraine Army terror units linked to mass executions
  16. A Dame to Kill for, Nymphomaniac, and Talmudic Ideology (Part II)
  17. NEO – Why the Scots Chose To Wear Their Chains With Pride
  18. NEO – Will the US use ISIL to attack Assad?
  19. Cocaine and Murder
  20. Three Israeli soldiers commit suicide: Report
  1. captain obvious: also the "war on drugs" that GOVT IMPORTS, that people turn to dealing or doing to survive or cope because there arent jobs.. and naturally CRIME goes up to justify ...
  2. captain obvious: what you're speaking of was directly caused by the District of Criminals ramming NAFTA-GATT through. young fathers cant find work to support a family or pay child support, get locked ...
  3. captain obvious: now we have this welfare-warfare "state" denying WMD's at the same time boasting about its Sampson Option, like Jeff Dunham's charachter "Achmed the undead terrorist" -SILENCE- I kill you!, good ...
  4. captain obvious: what is genocide or holocaust is relevant enough. my understanding is there werent even 1/2 million Jewish people in Germany before WW2, questioning 6 million number in much of Europe ...
  5. drbhelthi: - Also, the headline of The Washington Times, June 29, 1989, opens the window a bit on the deviate sexual activity that has characterized George H. W. Bush since his ...

Veterans Today Poll

For over 60 years, US Taxpayers have been funding Israel, Palestine and Middle East. Are you happy with return on investment or would you prefer those monies be invested at home instead?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Archives