Has the US lost the war in Syria? The blame game begins

THE US HAS OFFICIALLY LOST THE WAR IN SYRIA: REPORT

Written by Darius Shahtahmasebi; Originally appeared at TheAntiMedia.org

… via  Southfront

Being a jihadi is no longer as much fun as it used to be

[ Editor’s Note: I expected these “defeat” articles to pop up quickly with the publication of the Pentagon stating it would no longer support opposition groups that were not fighting ISIS. In The Century Foundation (CF) July 21 report excerpted below, Shahtahmasebi spotlights not the immorality of the analysis by the CF, but its amorality, a characteristic shared by many in the US coalition. They just don’t have any morals, so that is never an issue for them.

The focus is on the Overthrow-Assad plan not having been handled right, as not enough effort was put into it early enough. And the CF report quickly skips over how, when the US realized this, it pivoted over into bringing proxy terrorist forces used by its old partners in crime, the Saudis.

The UAE and Qatar followed along, with Turkey always pursuing an independent policy, while pretending to be an ally at times, and a victim at others. The Turkish wholesale looting of Aleppo and the oil business dealing with the jihadis should have gotten Turkey thrown out of the UN and NATO, but such things never happen in the real world.

Missing in the CF report is any acknowledgement that what happened in Syria was a war crime, and a crime against humanity on the Syrian people. I watched in 2014 at the elections how the Syrian people voted for Assad and the army in droves, as they had become inseparable by that point.

The US’ and Gulf States’ terror sponsoring, and Turkey’s callous looting made an easy decision for most Syrians as to whom the bigger evil was. And this was why we saw the huge push to get Assad to leave prior to elections.

The US knows he is going to win overwhelmingly. So the focus now should be do the State sponsors of terror have to pay the Syrian people reparations, and if so does their exist a forum to really determine such.

Darius correctly points out, as I have, and the CF does not, that the US has Balkanized Syrian with its replacing ISIS with the Kurds, to have a real claim to the land in the north. The US finally jumped on the better horse, and stopped beating the dead horse with “Assad must go”.

So let me tag The Century Foundation with being “fake critics”, as that seems to be the new popular “F-word”. Expect to see more folks like these crawling out from under their rocks to wallpaper over the crimes-against-humanity issue, as that is their job and why they getting funding. They are dependably useful, and VT is dependably exposing them for it. We thank Darius and Southfront for this excellent piece Jim W. Dean ]

Jim’s Editor’s Notes are solely crowdfunded via PayPal[email protected]

This includes research, needed field trips, Heritage TV Legacy archiving, and more – Thanks for helping out

*

–  First published  …  July 27,  2017  –

By ending the “secret” CIA program to arm and train Syrian rebels attempting to topple Bashar al-Assad in Syria, the Trump administration has accepted defeat in Syria, according to the Century Foundation, a prominent New York-based think tank.

The Century Foundation believes this signals an end to America’s commitment to achieving regime change in Syria, and it claims Washington’s attempt to topple Assad was halfhearted to begin with.

That being said, the Century Foundation also concedes that the program was doomed from the outset, stating:

“The problem with the program, which was reportedly running the CIA nearly a billion dollars a year, was not that it was under resourced or ‘insufficient in scale.’ The problem was that its logic was wrong and out of sync with the basic dynamics of the insurgency. [emphasis added]

Whatever the program had going for it, its ludicrous nature came to light after the conflict took full swing and opposition groups gathered momentum, as the think tank explained:

“But the covert program’s theory of the case also fell apart when when [sic] it became clear that the armed opposition—which was supposed to extract political concessions from the regime—was increasingly permeated by sectarian extremists and de-linked from the civilian interlocutors with which the regime was meant to compromise.” [emphasis added]

The think tank then went further to explain why this might signal the end of the regime change operation in Syria, as America’s allies have started to lose interest in pursuing an agenda they can no longer realistically achieve:

“Moreover, it’s not clear many opposition backers will be willing to continue with this or a similar effort absent America’s political cover and leading role. Opposition sponsors—including most of the Gulf states—are exhausted, if not checked out on the opposition entirely. Saudi Arabia, preoccupied now with its war in Yemen, is no longer seriously invested in regime change in Syria. Turkey has also give[n] up on regime change, instead preferring to negotiate with Russia over de-escalation and pursue its narrow national security ends.

Qatar has been a rogue actor, participating in the joint arms program but also independently supporting Islamist factions in partnership with Turkey. But, as Qatar’s dispute with Saudi and the United Arab Emirates drags on, its standing internationally and with the United States specifically is precarious. Donald Trump is already telling fundraisers that Qatar funds terrorism—if Qatar decides this is the opportune moment to go all-in on the Nusra Front, well, that’s its prerogative.” [emphasis added]

There is plenty of evidence to indicate that the U.S. aimed to achieve regime change as early as 2012 — or at the latest by 2013 — yet Assad has shown no signs of stepping down some five years later. Though this is clear to the outside world, the problem is that the United States is never one to accept defeat outright. Not, at least, until they have completely left their destructive mark on everything that moves in the very country they are struggling to forcibly bring to its knees.

In other words, the Century Foundation makes some insightful points but doesn’t touch on the fact that the Pentagon backs groups in Syria that pose an equal threat to the Syrian state and is still continuing to back these groups quite heavily.

The report doesn’t touch on the fact that, although it is common knowledge that the U.S. is partnering with the Kurds, the Trump administration is actually attempting to give the Kurds as much Syrian territory as possible, conveniently taking Syria’s most oil-rich region in the process.

This would take the region directly out of the hands of the Syrian government, which retains an isolated military outpost there.

What happens if the Syrian government decides it doesn’t want the American-backed Kurds to take their most oil-rich city? Will regime change be back on the agenda?

It is worth noting that the Trump administration has merely axed one program that has proved incredibly ineffective and counter-intuitive but has not rolled back any of its other operations in Syria. Nevertheless, as the Century Foundation explains in its report, the U.S. has basically killed the CIA’s support base for Syria’s al-Qaeda affiliates (which, at the very least, is progress to a degree).

Uncle Sam goes bonkers?

Despite this, the mainstream media has attempted to paint this issue as one in which Trump has handed Russia and Syria a treacherous victory in the Syrian conflict. At its peak, the CIA program was costing $1 billion a year to teach Syrian rebels potential terrorist tactics, yet Assad has only strengthened his position in the face of such an aggressive covert program.

It seems more likely that the U.S., which has vacillated between advocating and abandoning the strategy of regime change in the most schizophrenic of ways, is probably considering other approaches in regard to the Syrian conflict. At the very least, we should take note of the fact that Iran is Syria’s closest ally, and regime change in Iran has become an official U.S. strategy.

The other problem with this entire assessment is that no one is asking why on earth the United States is at war with Syria to begin with — not in relation to fighting the terror group ISIS, but more specifically, why the CIA was spending $1 billion a year to train rebels to overthrow a sovereign government in the first place.

Do we just accept this and dismiss it as unworthy of further scrutiny and criticism? If Russia spent $1 billion a year training rebels to overthrow the U.S. government, nobody would stand for it; and quite rightly so.

While the U.S. is accepting defeat when it comes to the Obama administration’s Syria strategy, its wars remain completely active in the Middle East. If anything, predicting the Trump administration’s next move is the tricky part, but you can be almost certain that the next move will not see anything close to a withdrawal from Syria or the wider Middle East region.

*

Related Posts:



The views expressed herein are the views of the author exclusively and not necessarily the views of VT, VT authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors, partners, technicians, or the Veterans Today Network and its assigns. LEGAL NOTICE - COMMENT POLICY

Posted by on July 28, 2017, With 5421 Reads Filed under Russia. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

FaceBook Comments

16 Responses to "Has the US lost the war in Syria? The blame game begins"

  1. Andrew_Bukanov(Russia)  July 30, 2017 at 10:36 am

    Dear Yankees, what the hell are you doing in the place where you are hatred, unwanted and cursed by Aborigines? what kind of Democracy you protect? 90% of your soldiers can’t site the Syria at the map. Yankee go home and reconstruct their ruins!

  2. kaho  July 29, 2017 at 11:38 pm

    This survey communicated last week by Russian military authorities, of recent progress and gains in terms of square kilometers (land) and kilometers (borders) underlines these views (maps)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Iv36uxExB8 (10:32 w. English subs)

    Брифинг начальника ГОУ ГШ ВС РФ генерал-полковника С.Ф. Рудского (24.07.2017)
    (Briefing of the Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation Colonel-General S.F. Rudsky (July 24, 2017))
    Минобороны России (Russian MoD)

  3. Cold Wind  July 29, 2017 at 4:02 am

    The critical factor here in appreciating the viability of the US strategy to divide Syria, is that Russia itself has all but acceded to the idea of a independent Kurdish State. When asked about the prospect Putin answered: “we can’t stop it”, or something to this effect. Doubtless, this comment was taken as a green light for US (read Israel) planners. One can only wonder what Assad’s response might have been, but of course he could do nothing publicly to address the Russian version of realpolitik. Assad would not survive one day without Russia, but ironically a US/Israel controlled Kurdish state will lead to his inevitable demise.

    • Jim W. Dean, Managing Editor  July 29, 2017 at 5:35 am

      This is maneuvering by the Kurds prior to political talks. Assad has long indicated flexibility, but I suspect that will be along the lines of a federated state. Both Russia and the US are on record for supporting Syrian territorial integrity, even Turkey when it came into the Tripartite ground. The wiggle room for the all is they claim “conducting anti-terrorists operations” are excepted, so all they have to do is rig a few false flag terror attacks and move into wherever they want if they have the military power, “to defend themselves”. The air will be going out of that tire as ISIS gets removed. In Idlib, with HTS getting control, they will become open targets as al-Qaeda forces. Damascus can deal with them when Deir Ezzor is over.

    • Dr. Abu-Bakr Susta  July 29, 2017 at 1:20 pm

      CW: Although Putin & Russia might say that they can’t stop the Kurds, Israel & the crumbling U.S.-led coalition from Balkanizing Syria, the false premise is that Kurds would want & fight for an independent Kurdish country at the expense of a modicum of peace & stability in Iraq & Syria etc. False!

      Kurdish leaders know that the crumbling U.S.-led coalition & Israel are using the Kurds to maintain chaos, conflict & confusion in the Mideast; but the Kurds are also using the U.S.-led coalition & Israel to get arms, ammo & funding to defeat IS/Daesh & other US/Bibi-backed terrorists in Syria — to achieve their interim objective of a cessation of major hostilities. Putin & Russia know this. Trump, Bibi & Co. are quasi-clueless.

  4. mb.  July 29, 2017 at 3:11 am

    Like with any war : the elite won, the people lost.

    • mb.  July 29, 2017 at 3:11 am

      … and the media had loads of content.

  5. wjabbe  July 28, 2017 at 4:28 pm

    http://www.breitbart.com/national-security/2017/07/27/putin-signs-deal-keep-russian-airbase-syria-another-half-century/ I believe this deal between Syria and Russia is good news and a beginning of defeat for the vulchers U.S., Israel, Turkey, Saudis, etc. in Syria. Putin signed the deal today. What is needed now is for Russia and Syria to move beyond this limited deal and join each other for the long term security of both against the war criminals the U.S., Israel and elsewhere who seek to steal it from Syria. I believe this is the only solution and the only one which can be implemented non violently. Iran could also be a part of this voluntary annexation. Then the U.S. and other thugs must be booted out permanently.

    • JohnZ  July 28, 2017 at 4:45 pm

      Which means that Syria could end up with a few nukes of their own or at least with such advanced military capabilities that even israel would be hesitant to attack.
      As far as newsworthiness is concerned, Breitbart should be highly suspect. S reported here at VT, is one of the zionist disinfo sites.
      I agree on your last point: the U.S. and its cohorts in crime need to leave Syria…and Iraq….and Afghanistan.

    • wjabbe  July 28, 2017 at 4:46 pm

      “A friend in need is a friend indeed.” Russia has put everything on the line for Syria and its peoples and I am sure all of them know and understand this. Untold billions of dollars spent, losses of lives, planes, armor and sometimes even pride, but they have stuck with them through and through. Even the beloved Russian Choir might be gone as a result of this fight. Russia and Syria are blood brothers today. They are inseparable Siamese Twins. If the U.S. had any moral values whatsoever left, they would move out today this instant and admit they were totally wrong. How can the whole U.S. government be arrested and jailed, because if such a thing a true justice existed this would be done. Some of us U.S. Citizens do not approve of the criminal misconduct of the United States of America mostly in secret via the outlaw CIA agency which we have no control over. Some day hopefully this criminal enterprise will be shut down forever.

    • wjabbe  July 28, 2017 at 5:24 pm

      “I have no use for liars, national, international, or those found in private life.”
      Theodore Roosevelt. This simple statement, by one of America’s greatest presidents, responsible for most of our fabulous national parks among other great achievements, basically summarizes the problem of America today. Lying and cheating at the highest or “lowest” levels to all citizens, totally against all the basic principles of openness of the great Founders of this country. This once great nation will never return to its original position unless and until all this immoral lying and cheating is brought to a halt. The corollary to this is that all secrecy in government must end because secrecy is the enemy of the truth.

  6. Trakkath  July 28, 2017 at 3:05 pm

    It should be renamed to Murder & Looter Inc, so everyone knows the most US inhabitants or other countries´citizen have nothing to do with them. They are hiding behind this US and other signs and flags. A pirate flag would be their best with Skull and Bones.

  7. JohnZ  July 28, 2017 at 1:12 pm

    I believe the answer to why America is waging war n Syria can be easily answered by Gen Wesley Clark. After all, he was given notice of the plan to take down 7 countries in 5 years for israel’s oded yinon plan.
    We witness to the criminality of Washington, the Pentagram and the CIA as well as the British government, Saudi Arabia and most of all, israel.
    The destruction and frightful loss of human life bear witness to the crimes of these people and yes, the American people bear as much of the guilt, especially with the xtian zionists whose blind support of israel and the immense power of the israeli lobby in Washington has not only destroyed these nations but is also destroying America.
    The people of Iraq, Syria, Libya and Afghanistan deserve total restitution, which should be paid out of the aid money that would have been given to israel. The $6 trillion dollars the Pentagram cannot account for, has for all practical purposes, disappeared over an event horizon and into a black hole.

    • JohnZ  July 28, 2017 at 1:23 pm

      America has lost its sanity. It will continue these wars in the middle east until it is thoroughly exhausted. The zionists could care less. Let it be so.
      Ever since the First Gulf War, which I did not support, the U.S. has been nothing more than a thug for israel, doing its dirty work with the military as nothing more than a mercenary for zionism.
      The big question is: how do we right this awful wrong or is it simply too late for America? Is the curtain coming down on America and we see it now happening in its economy, as it continues to blunder across the planet from one military and foreign policy disaster after another. If America continues to do so, its future of complete collapse and failure is assured.
      Then what?

    • Eduardo  July 28, 2017 at 3:07 pm

      Then what? US or what will be left will get a loan from their favourite banksters and start to rebuilt with the help of foreign mercenaries and displaced people from over the world. All will be ready to implement a NWO and the rulers are finally getting their way. AI will control and monitor the new Army and space travel to start a new colony will be compulsory as it will become difficult for mankind to survive the pit of hell Earth.

    • roger  July 28, 2017 at 8:05 pm

      JohnZ: Fully agree with you on a few NuKs in Syria hands. It would be a paralell case to the N. Korea’s: Too close to strategic allies to have even a “surgical procedure”. The weapons could be in the classic under two key control.but its mere existence in a short distance would keep Israelis day and night awake
      Exhaustive analysis on the dangers, would lead to assess the loyalty of Assad’s inner circle and,a B plan in case Assad disappears and replaced by a “westernized” general like Egypt’s Sisi. I’ll bet Mossad is already planning outcomes because, Assad, according to their hebrew mind, doesn’t have the size or the entity to forestall their Yinon plans. ,, . .

You must be logged in to post a comment Login


TOP 50 READ ARTICLES THIS MONTH
From Veterans Today Network