Special Note: As a Palestinian-American committed to the One State Solution for all of its people, I take a very strong exception to Senator Schumer’s claim Palestine is his.
In his shameful appeasement at the recent AIPAC convention where Zionists and non-Zionist politicians are ordered to recite their pledge of allegiance to Israel and line up to “kiss ass” always under constant fear from AIPAC to lose their jobs, Senator Schumer an Israeli First and foremost, presented himself as Israeli who believed that the Torah is a “Real Estate Book and Deed” granted by G-d and not as most scholars agree is written by scholars and Rabbis certainly not Moses.
He denounced Arabs and Palestinians as people in self-denial, who do not believe in the Torah and who do not believe that G-d gave the land of Palestine to the Israelis and Zionism. He stood up and declared that the conflict with Israel is the Arabs and Palestinian refusal to recognize Israel as a “Jewish State” as state where he counted himself as member and citizen of the state. Talk about dual loyalty?
Senator Chuck Schumer an Israeli First never an American First concluding the essence of the conflict in that the Arabs and Muslims refusal to believe in the Torah “Of course, we say it’s our land, the Torah says it, but they don’t believe in the Torah. So that’s the reason there is no peace.
They invent reasons, but they do not believe in a Jewish state and that is why we, in America must stand strong with Israel through the thick and thin.” Did he say as US senator that “we say it is our land” for sure he was not refereeing to his land as the US, but Israel.
I am not a religious scholars and do not pretend to be one, though many years ago while living in Geneva I bought and read the 5 Books of Moses. But that was long ago, and memory tends to fail me at my age. So I did some research and interestingly enough I looked up the Torah to understand what Senator Schumer has to say.
Elon Gilad an Israeli scholars wrote back in 22 October 2014 and writing in Haaretz under the title “Who Wrote the Torah? Concluding “for thousands of years’ people believed that the five books of the Pentateuch were written by Moses, but it couldn’t have been, academic say.’
Gilad base his conclusion on “four characteristics recurring in the Torah. (1) The language used in different sections differs widely. (2) Varying ideology. (3) Contradictions in the narrative, (4) The text is strangely repetitive in part, for no obvious reason, indicating that two versions of a single story were included.”
Here is where I or we have a problem. Do we believe that G-d wrote the book and delivered it to Moses in the full text or simply made it simple to Moses by giving him the Ten Commandments which nowhere the “promised land” was mentioned, even if there were a “promise” does Schumer and his elks are deemed beneficiaries of such promise.
If the Torah was not written by Moses or by G-d why should be believe what Senator Schumer wants to believe that G-d or Moses acting as “real estate agents” and having done a full title search concluded that Senator Schumer is entitled to the land of Palestine at the exclusion of all those who inhabited the land over tens of thousands of years. In other words Senator Schumer believes in ethnic cleansing not different from the one exercised in Germany.
Yes, Senator Schumer we do not believe in the promise land, nor do we believe that G-d or Moses granted you or Bibi Netanyahu or Avigdor Lieberman the land of Palestine, and it is not true that the Arabs and Palestinian failings to recognize Israeli as a Jewish State is the reason for the conflict. It seems your selective memory is not helping you.
You and your likes within the American Zionist movement have selective memories certainly selective and shameful morality, hypocrisy and unconscionable behavior. You chose to forget the forced exiled of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homeland in order for Secular Zionists to establish your colonial settler state. You chose to forget the destructions of over 550 villages and the desecrations of mosques and churches and cemeteries. You chose to forget the ethnic cleansing of tens of thousands of Palestinians from Jerusalem and the constant house demolitions under so many pretenses and the outright theft of properties by your “people” and the over 550 humiliating “security checkpoints” subjecting millions of Palestinians to shameful humiliations on a daily basis. You chose to forget the targeted killings and the assault by your “people” on places of worships both Christians and Muslims and the burning and uprooting’s of hundreds of thousands of olive trees and the poisoning of water wells by your “Hill Top Jews”.
No, Senator Schumer we do believe in the Torah as a Holy Book for the Jews but not a Real Estate Book for Zionists like you, and we do believe and recognize “Jewish values” as enshrined in the Ten Commandments but we do not believe in your racist Zionism certainly we do not believe that you are entitled to the land of Palestine. No Mr. Schumer Palestine is not your Fucking Land.
“Listen to my song WE EXIST and remember Palestine was NEVER a land without a people. It was always a land with people. Just saying so does NOT make it true! TIME TO START SHOWING RESPECT FOR OTHERS and STOP STEALING their stuff and dignity pretending it does NOT count. IT DOES!
USA is in a free fall from grace because it steps all over people. It has to stop! Racism! Hate! Stealing from indigenous peoples for greed and power in the name of GOD is wrong! Change starts from you, from home…. change your thinking, your actions and stand with your fellow man…. BUILD BRIDGES to our future! NOT Walls! Stand for our collective future! BE SOMETHING SPECIAL!” Signed Johnny Punish (Facebook March 19, 2018)