[Editor’s note: There is no doubt in my mind that the Allied bombing campaign against Germany in WW2 was one of the worst war crimes ever committed. While certain despicable self-proclaimed intelligence experts laud the deaths of German civilians as a result of the bombing as a ‘glorious slaughter’ and lament that ‘we didn’t kill enough of them’ I feel only disgust and revulsion at what was done to the German people by my forebears.
The British people were conned into believing that the bombing of German cities was helping to win the war, that it was justified because those horrid Nazis were slaughtering innocent Jews and others they deemed ‘untermensch’; the simple truth is it did nothing to shorten the war, rather it prolonged it by giving the German fighting men a fierce determination to resist and gain some degree of vengeance for the slaughter of their loved one and the destruction of their homes.
The German bombing of Britain was a mere drop n the ocean compared to the immense scale of the slaughter and destruction the Allies wreaked on Germany, in no way, shape or form can the two bombing campaigns be compared, so disproportionate are they when compared. Another great lie, still believed by many in Britain was that the goal of the war and the bombing campaign was to defeat the Nazis, in truth, as the butcher and arch criminal Churchill admitted postwar, the real intent was to destroy Germany and it’s people.
The bombing was not aimed at the German war industries, the excuse given that attempts at targeting those industries failed due to a lack of precision is paper thin and the tactic of area bombing, where entire cities were levelled can in no way be justified in terms of the damage it did to German war industries. Churchill also admitted that much of German industry had not even been targeted, for the callous and cynical reason that when the war was won, we would inherit a desert of our own making and in fact, the Allied rulers wanted to preserve as much of Germany’s industry as possible, so that there would be something left worth stealing once the war ended.
The BBC article is wrong, Hamburg, as deadly and horrific as it was, was not the deadliest nor most destructive raid of the war, that dubious distinction goes to Dresden where, just scant weeks before the end of the war, hundreds of thousands of German civilians met their end in a true holocaust, consumed by the firestorm created by over a thousand Allied aircraft. The official record still denies the death toll was more than 30-odd thousands and as horrific and tragic as that number is, the true figure is a factor of 10 or more greater.
We must never forget the Allied bombing of Germany and we must never allow ourselves to be deceived into believing it was in any way justified, rather, we must educate ourselves and future generations to the truth of the aerial slaughter inflicted on the German people. The words of General Patton are most appropriate – ‘we have destroyed the last decent people in Europe’. Ian]
Operation Gomorrah: Firestorm created ‘Germany’s Nagasaki’
This story contains graphic images.
The centenary of the RAF not only coincides with the 75th anniversary of one of its most famous missions – the Dambusters – but also with one of its most controversial.
Kate Hoffmeister, 19, was trying to escape the furnace her Hamburg neighbourhood had become.
“I struggled to run against the wind in the middle of the street… we couldn’t go on across [the road] because the asphalt had melted.
“There were people on the roadway, some already dead, some still lying alive but stuck in the asphalt. They must have rushed on to the roadway without thinking.
“Their feet have got stuck and they had put out their hands to try and get out again. They were on their hands and knees screaming.”
The attack on Hamburg, Germany’s second largest city, would be known as Operation Gomorrah, after the biblical city wiped out by fire and brimstone.
Air raids were nothing new. The agonies of Guernica, Warsaw, Rotterdam, London, Coventry and Cologne, where raids killed hundreds, were already seared on the international consciousness.
But Gomorrah in July 1943 would be on a new and terrible scale – unmatched by any other single Allied air attack in Europe during World War Two.
Keith Lowe, author of Inferno, a book about the attack, said: “There is in the UK a tendency to equate what happened in Hamburg and Dresden with what happened in London and Coventry.
“But Hamburg is on a completely different level – it is more comparable with what happened in Nagasaki.”
Gomorrah was rooted in failure. Bomber Command’s early efforts were blackly laughable, with only a tiny percentage of bombs falling anywhere near their targets.
In 1941 it was calculated it took five tonnes of bombs to kill one German. The numbers of enemy dead were almost the same as Allied aircrews lost.
This prompted a change in tactics. Specific industrial targets were mostly abandoned.
Mr Lowe said: “Hamburg was the result of a deliberate policy. In a way it would be understandable – if you can’t hit, say, an aircraft factory alone, you can try and hit anything around it.
“But this went further – it stopped trying to hit the aircraft factory, it specifically targeted the workers and their families.”
In 1942 a decision was taken by the War Cabinet and the Air Staff to destroy all of Germany’s cities with populations over 100,000, targeting “the morale of the enemy civil population – in particular the industrial workers”.
By the following year Bomber Command had enough aircraft, a single-minded leader in Arthur Harris and the technical knowledge to carry this plan out.
Mr Lowe says: “Experience and extensive testing had shown a mix of high explosives and incendiaries was the most destructive combination.
“The big bombs blocked roads, shattered water mains and, crucially, blew out windows and roofs.
“Then thousands of incendiaries could start fires to cause intensive destruction.”
Gomorrah – with eight days of bombing by the RAF and USAF from 24 July – would prove these theories.
In the event, a number of circumstances magnified Hamburg’s suffering.
It had been a hot summer and the city was tinder dry. Emergency teams were busy dealing with fires from earlier raids in the western districts.
And the RAF had a secret weapon – codenamed Window.
Tens of thousands of strips of aluminium paper were launched from planes, creating a snowstorm of reflected radar signals and effectively blinding the fearsome German defences.
Almost unhindered, at 00:55am the first of more than 720 heavily laden bombers arrived over the tightly packed workers’ apartments in the east of the city.
In the next few hours, a new word was added to the dictionary of war – firestorm (feuersturm).
The phenomenon matched the apocalyptic name of the operation. Something akin to the wrath of God was visited on the city.
Concentrated, unchecked fires linked up to turn parts of Hamburg into a furnace. Hot air soared into the sky, sucking more from street level.
Winds reached speeds of up to 150mph (240km/h) and temperatures reached at least 800C. Wood, fabric and flesh blazed. Glass exploded, metal twisted, stonework glowed dull red.
Packed apartment blocks became shells within minutes.
Streets became tunnels of screaming hurricane-force winds – one survivor recalled a noise “like an old church organ when someone is playing all the notes at once”.
Operation Gomorrah timeline
- 24-25 July: Night raid by about 790 RAF bombers. First use of Window
- 25 July: Day raid by about 120 USAF bombers
- 26 July: Day raid by about 50 USAF bombers
- 27-28 July: Night raid by about 780 RAF bombers. Firestorm
- 28 July: Evacuation of Hamburg ordered
- 29-30 July: Night raid by about 770 RAF bombers. Second Firestorm
- 2-3 August: Night raid by about 740 RAF Bombers, which were scattered by bad weather
Already stretched fire crews were overwhelmed.
They faced a “sea of fire”, with clothes and vehicles bursting into flames. One described rescue efforts as like “throwing a drop of water on a hot stone”.
The tornado, filled with fire, embers and debris, sucked people – especially the old and young – towards the fire.
Henni Klank fled her apartment with her husband and baby only when the curtains were on fire and the ceiling began to crack.
“At this moment something snapped in a neighbour and, caught up in a panic, he took his bed cover and wanted out.
“None of us could stop him. We saw him still, but only as a living torch carried by the firestorm, ‘flying through the air’.”
Cowering in a shelter, her family faced the same terrible choice as thousands of others that night: stay put and risk being buried, suffocated or even cooked, or chance the hellish conditions outside.
With oxygen becoming so thin candles were fading, they broke down a cellar wall to escape.
They faced a scene from the end of days.
She said: “We came out… into a thundering, blazing hell. The streets were burning, the trees were burning and the tops of them were bent [by the wind] right down to the street.
“Burning horses out of the Hertz hauling business ran past us. The air was burning; simply everything was burning.”
An area of about 4 sq miles (10 sq km) – roughly equivalent to the area of London from Kings Cross to the Thames, Hyde Park Corner to the Tower of London – was incinerated.
And that was just the firestorm.
Devastation was spread over roughly 12 sq miles (31 sq km). At the height of the raid 16,000 apartment buildings, with frontages of 133 miles (214km), home to nearly 450,000 people, were ablaze.
Kate Hoffmeister, who had seen the people stuck on the melted road, found herself, her mother and her Aunt Emma trapped by burning trees.
A grassy bank offered some shelter: “I suggested we roll down this bank… I went and I think I rolled over some people who were still alive. I lost my aunt at that point.
“By then my face and arms and legs had been burnt so badly I could only act by touch.”
Thousands of feet above, RAF aircrews were elated by the success of Window and awed by the power of the raid.
Air gunner Douglas Fry recalled it as: “Brilliant, better than [earlier raids]. The fires were incredibly fierce; you couldn’t see a black spot amongst this huge sheet of flame which covered acres and acres.
“We didn’t know about the firestorm – we just knew the target was well alight, which meant a good raid.”
Flying Officer Trevor Timperley said: “The blaze was unimaginable. I remember saying to the navigator, who was engrossed with his charts: ‘For Christ’s sake, Smithy, come and see this. You’ll never see the like of it again!’
“But Hamburg raised for me for the first time the ethics of bombing.
“I took the view so-called civilians were part of the German war machine… the only ones you are left with were the children… they were not involved, so you were left with a terrible feeling about them.”
Other aircrews reported being able to feel the heat, getting soot over their aircraft and even the smell of roasting flesh.
Operation Gomorrah ran until 3 August 1943 and involved six major raids. Estimates of the dead vary between 34,000 and 43,000.
Records show the destruction of 580 industrial plants 2,632 businesses, 379 office buildings, 24 hospitals, 277 schools and 257 government or Nazi party buildings.
Somewhere upwards of half of all homes in the city were destroyed. A million of the 1.7m population fled.
Kate Hoffmeister lost her aunt, father and two uncles, but later found she was in the same hospital as her mother.
Henni Klank and her family escaped in a boat packed with traumatised women and children, and had a last glimpse of the city covered in smoke “as if to hide the horror”.
But for all the cost, what was the effect on Nazi Germany’s war effort?
Dr Malte Thiessen, professor of contemporary European history, says: “News of the attacks ran like wildfire. Rumours of uprisings were making the rounds, fear and panic filled other cities that saw themselves next on the ‘hit list’.
“Such fears were felt up to the top, with Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels writing in his diary about the ‘Sword of Damocles hovering over Germany’.”
Dr Thiessen says Hamburg was “paralysed” for months after the attacks.
“Although many arms factories and refineries were operational again in early 1944, demoralisation and destruction remained a long-term problem that also weakened war production.
“And demands to protect the home front had a practical impact, in diverting arms from the battlefields, and a psychological impact, by raising questions on the fronts about was happening to loved ones at home,” he says.
Harris was triumphant. Newsreels and papers claimed “Hamburg smashed!” and trumpeted the 40,000 death toll.
Mr Lowe says: “To Harris, this showed that bombing alone could end the war and he pursued this idea.
“He carried on the policy of trying to wipe out cities, through Berlin and Dresden and dozens of others, to the end of the war, despite mounting evidence that hitting specific targets was both possible and more effective.”
But Hamburg proved hard to repeat. Improved defences and greater distances made the bombing campaign a costly slog. Even devastating raids like Dresden, in the last days of the war, saw fewer people killed.
Much of Hamburg was not rebuilt for decades and, although partially preserved, St Nicholas’ Church was left as a shell.
It is in the cellar of this gutted building – which was briefly the tallest tower in the world – that a museum about the firestorm has been set up, and where the anniversary of the operation is being marked with an exhibition.
Victor Baeyens, one of the hundreds of concentration camp inmates forced to help clear the bodies and bombs from the ruins of Hamburg, wrote later the scale of destruction stunned even the prisoners.
“When listening to those horror stories we no longer broke into cheers as we did during the air raid itself.
“We were soberly thinking of the drama of mothers looking for their children and vice versa. What a curse war is.”
His studies in history and background in the media industry have given him a keen insight into the use of mass media as a creator of conflict in the modern world.
His favored areas of study include state-sponsored terrorism, media manufactured reality and the role of intelligence services in manipulation of populations and the perception of events.