by Jim W. Dean, VT Editor, … with New Eastern Outlook, Moscow
[ Note: I had to write this fast, as I expected NEO to get half a dozen submissions on the Trump-Syria pullout. NEO publishing slots are cherished, as they only post two or three articles a day, as they only do features.
They have a large writing pool, so the competition is intense. My writing style prefers to not get ahead of a story when there are only a few pieces of the puzzle in view, which all the outlets have and are repeating as news with no analysis.
But with the Intel backgrounds we have here at VT, we are experienced at using dual track analysis, taking a look at what is in front of us to make sure it is real; and then also, which separates us, looking for what is not there, that should be.
Often the gaps in the official story are where you eventually find the biggest clues to what the background game is on a breaking event. So, as soon as I saw that Trump had sprung this on everybody, pissing a lot of them off, a story line came to me “Why did he do it this way?”
Major government departments, especially the Pentagon and State are used to getting a respectful preview of planned major events so they know better what to say to the press so they don’t look clueless. I see this as Trump not wanting to share the stage, playing Mr. Executive with the spotlight just on him.
The issue of what Erdogan was really going to do with the Kurds had been on the VT table for days, and we were pinging our sources for input. Then, out of left field comes “The Donald”, of all people, grabbing the world stage just before Christmas.
My missive below is not a “Who dun it”, but a review of some of the options and motivations of those involved. Former Secretary of State John Kerry in his book quoted a good line from Netanyahu, “In the Mideast, everybody lies.” I got a chuckle, as it is the same in many other places.
When everybody is lying, truth does not have much a chance, the illegitimate child that know one will admit to. VT is used to being around a lot of lying, as we have new sources trying to con us all the time. One has to develop a sixth sense, while the support people are fact checking as fast as they can on someone’s story.
If Trump did just pull this out of his butt, there may not be too many people to spill the beans on how it went down. I have never interviewed a butt before, and would consider it a rather substantial demotion…that my time had come to move on.
Thanks in advance for reading my attempt to pull something out of the great American chaos-maker’s latest salvo – the Great American Syria withdrawal with no organizational preparation or even notification that it was coming. The Pentagon is pissed off beyond belief, and Mattis saying goodbye could be all they could do about it, for now… JD ]
Jim's Editor’s Notes are solely crowdfunded via PayPal
Jim's work includes research, field trips, Heritage TV Legacy archiving & more. Thanks for helping. Click to donate >>
– First published … December 20, 2018 –
Washington NeoCons are in a rage over the Trump news of his reported pull out of all American troops from Syria. This is not literally true of course, but I will get to that in a minute. First we must go over what was said leading up to the surprise move to get some clues as to why Trump pulled this trigger now.
On the Pentagon front, it appears they were caught flatfooted. Joint Chief of Staff General Dunford recently claimed a “stabilization force” of 35-40,000 would need to be trained to protect Syria from an ISIS resurgence. That made me wonder what the heck the US have been doing all of these years there if not training people, including many going over to the jihadis, even donating their weapons.
This surprise move will go down in history as Trump’s Christmas surprise. So let us try to peel the layers off this event to see what could really be going on inside.
Who knew the announcement was coming?
It apparently caught everyone flatfooted. The proof came when the Pentagon was initially asked how long it would take to bring the troops home; it had to replay that “We are working on that now.” The military brass does not like to be blindsided with something like this.
We also did not hear a word from John Bolton or Nikki Haley, who would usually have been out front on a move like this. Trump took all the credit like he usually does with “We beat ISIS, we won and we are going home like I said we would” statement.
The man does love short simple explanations for everything. He will crow about his defeating ISIS in his State of the Union address in January, but have to share it with the Joint Chiefs of Staff all sitting on the front row.
It seems no one in Congress was tipped off either, and they let the world know quickly. The first out of the gate were the dependable Israel-firsters, Senators Mark Rubio and Lindsey Graham. Graham called it an “Obama-like mistake”.
Rubio went further, describing it as a “colossal” mistake and a “grave error that’s going to have significant repercussions in the months and years to come.”
This is what senior Senators do when a president leaves them out of the loop on a major policy shift. All of the pro-war and pro-Israeli think tanks will be added to this “big mistake” choir.
Israel will be livid because now Assad will not have the US forces on his Northern and Western flanks, which will make it easier for him to focus on the Idlib problem and face off the Israelis in the Golan Heights, who will be looking to stir up trouble. Nothing scares militant Zionists more than the prospect of peace.
Was the recent Syrian peace process success a last straw for Trump?
Intelligence analysts always quickly ask the key question, why now? Why did Trump not wait until after the Christmas recess, and even his State of the Union address, to give the new Congress some time to get its bearings.
Some might pose that, with the Democrats publicly reveling in their threats to initiate a number of investigations into Mr. Trump’s scandal closet, he wanted to clear Syria off his desk. Others might say that he wanted to get out before getting caught in a bind with a Turkish invasion into northern Syria that would kill US troops, along with the problems that would cause.
Erdogan had his invasion force in its jump off positions and was bombing YPG strong points. Did Trump make a deal with Erdogan that if he would back off from attacking the Kurds and buy the Patriot missiles, then Trump would pull out? The quickness of the move strongly indicates that a deal was made that had to go publicly quickly to seal it. We will know soon with the mountain of post analysis that is coming over the next few days.
Last week saw the Arab League boycott of Assad broken with the visit by Sudan’s president, and the UN completing the first organizational steps in creating Syria’s new Constitutional Committee, with the US playing no role whatsoever. They surely will be fighting like cats and dogs over the new Constitution, but that will be a relief for the Syrian people, especially those who are returning home after years as refugees.
The refugees are a growing element of Assad supporters, as they know that he and the Syrian army, with Russia and Iran’s help, saved them from the jaws of the US-coalition proxy terror war. I think Trump could see that any chance of getting a US puppet in control of Syria was down to zero.
What does leaving really mean?
This is not a trick question. The White House press secretary stated that the US would start transitioning to the next stage of its Syrian campaign, and it would work with its allies to continue the fight.
This is a confusing statement, due to its widely being known that the US Coalition ran many of the ISIS units, was particularly active in extricating commanders to use in the future, and sent foot soldiers to Afghanistan to stoke the growing chaos there.
Afternoon reports state that 2000 troops were coming home, with all the State Department people getting out in the next 24 hours, meaning there was only one plane load and they were all at one location. But the real number has always been much bigger.
Special operations are a big outsourced business these days. Eric Prince has been negotiating with the US to replace US Afghanistan troops with his private army contractors, and doing so publicly. And while some US troops will be coming home, many could be shifted to the two new US bases built just over the border in Iraq, in close support positions for the US Kurdish allies inside Syria.
The air wing of the US coalition is not leaving and will be on call for bombing missions when ordered to support what the White House called the next phase. The 2000 US troops could be replaced quickly by another coalition member’s troops. The Gulf States have been supporting ISIS, the Muslim Brotherhood, and countless opposition groups inside Syria. We did not hear a peep out of any of them today.
Where do we go from here
Expect the Russians to announce a troop pull down in response to the US leaving, as they have done this in the past during de-escalations. That of course would change quickly if the Gulf States, for example, were to move their Yemen mercenaries to Syria as part of the Yemen War winding down.
Syria’s next military move is anyone’s guess. Will it use the US pullout to begin reasserting itself over Arab territory that the Kurds took over with US backing? Or will Assad want to remove the Idlib jihadi thorn in his side, as no political process can result in a vote if they are not cleared out of Idlib?
Russia, Turkey and Iran have been guarantors of the peace process, where one of the main planks is that Syrian territory is not to become Balkanized by foreign powers. Since they are there at the invitation of Syria they can legally engage any force attacking Syria, if they choose.
Did Trump need a distraction?
Trump needed a big play here to get the press off his Mueller investigation problems, especially with the National Inquirer accepting a “no prosecution” deal by admitting that it helped Trump pay off sexual flings to protect his election candidacy, a felony. With both the National Inquirer and his own attorney rolling over on him, Trump is now a dead man walking on that charge.
The New York Attorney General closed down the Trump Foundation this week for the Trump family using it as a tax dodge and a promotional vehicle to bolster their business and political interests.
New York is looking into more of Trump’s dirty laundry in 2019, which looks like it will be a tougher year for him than 2018 has been. Will winning the presidency ironically be the ultimate downfall of Trump.
Jim W. Dean, managing editor for VT, producer/host of Heritage TV Atlanta, specially for the online magazine “New Eastern Outlook”.
Jim W. Dean is VT Editor Emeritus. He was an active editor on VT from 2010-2022. He was involved in operations, development, and writing, plus an active schedule of TV and radio interviews. He now writes and posts periodically for VT.
ATTENTION READERSWe See The World From All Sides and Want YOU To Be Fully Informed
In fact, intentional disinformation is a disgraceful scourge in media today. So to assuage any possible errant incorrect information posted herein, we strongly encourage you to seek corroboration from other non-VT sources before forming an educated opinion.
About VT - Policies & Disclosures - Comment Policy
Dialing a war back means downsizing the troop need, which includes officers. Historically those that are nearing one of the retirement slots with pay jumps, 20, 25 and 30 have a higher probability of getting cut as the gov saves on the lower pension level. My brother came out as a Lt. Colonel about 18 months before his 30 years, which included four of ROTC, due to a heart attack he had had. He thought all the stories about smoking being bad for you was all Leftie stuff. But he was lucky, because his superiors handling his final exit papers proposed giving him a higher disability percentage to compensate for the lower pension. He jumped on it. When Bush era people starting dropping hints during interviews that the War of Terror could go on for a decade or, a giant smile spread across the officer corp for all the promotions that would be in the pipeline. The six figure private contractor corruption did not crank up right away, but came on like a steamroller when it did.
What if they are getting the troops out of the way of a nuclear bombing by Izrahell?
Ratings and public opinion are the last remaining weapon. This announcement comes right in the belly of the whale, the one place where consensus states to hold off for 3 days.
There is deception here. So, I hesitate to give him any credit for this, until we see the angle. My question would be, ‘Is it possible for CIC to hire mercs, and activate the op under secrecy?”
Is this punishment for Israel, to get them moving on his “peace deal”, which frankly, if announced would take some heat off, and give him something big for the SOTU.
Mattis was born on day 20, day of dog, which was also yesterday. In the 260 round, it was Putins day. Mattis barked and Putin howled at the moon.
” So, I hesitate to give him any credit for this, until we see the angle. ” Amen on this Dave. And are the US troops on the ground going to be in Ukraine, just a shift in focus? Or was the strategy, that giving up on Syria a part of his wanting to rack up a list of campaign pledges for the 2020 race?
We had the news last night, to my surprise, that Trump had stopped the bombing, too. Nothing pisses the military off more than stopping live combat where they have massive superiority. Besides making a lot of people “combat veterans”, despite their being deployed in an illegal war, it removes their being able to train troops in real combat situations, which frankly is the best kind of training. Russia did the same thing, cycling all of its pilots and ground crews through Syria so they all know what the real deal is like. Their combat efficiency went up by a multiple, something else that made the Pentagon unhappy, but it was our overly aggressive policy that caused that, once again a failed policy except for destroying another country to make and example for others to are thinking about resisting. How are things in Crimea now?
We probably need more military at the border wall, right? Bring all the boys and girls home, then go after the puppet masters who control the Fed and military incompetent complex.
It is just a patchwork quilt the three Fates are putting together for Trump at a rather hurried pace which some might describe as break-neck speed with the noose tightening round his roundy neck over a very secure trapdoor. I don’t imagine Turkey strong-armed him as unless it gets Bibi’s imprimatur first the Don dare not make a move. My guess, understated as it might be says Russia was now primed to push the End Game with Ergodan in cahoots and Israel forced to batten down the hatches is detached to a degree where their influence is actually minimal. Nobody cares for the Kurds and Trump, the writing on the wall like it was for Belshazzar, reacted off the cuff in vainglorious fashion put his finger in the dam of damning indictments coming his way with a rush, the way the waters come down at Lodore.
“Here it comes sparkling,
And there it lies darkling;
Now smoking and frothing
Its tumult and wrath in,
Till, in this rapid race
On which it is bent,
It reaches the place
Of its steep descent.”
– Robert Southey
“Me thinks you doth protest too much”. How many times have writers and editors of VT complained of the U.S. presence in Syria as being totally illegal as invaders? Israel Lover Trump granted your wish and ordered them out. But now everybody is criticizing him for this Christmas present. Let’s watch and see if he really does it and give him credit for having the gut to finally do the right thing here. How about the whole Congress of Israel lover whores doing us a favor and resigning en mass? I don’t like Trump and I don’t like Congress and I don’t like lying four star generals as in 9/11/01 but I like this action of Trump. By the way he did consult with Netanyahu before making this decision as an article I posted from an Israeii newspaper shows from their side.
Im with you wjabbe . Hopefully awaiting the return of many of our military members !
Please post the link, thanks.
Comments are closed.