The real importance of Israel’s assassination of Iranian scientist Mohsen Fakhrizadeh has not been fully understood. It wasn’t just an effort to sabotage Biden’s diplomacy with Iran. It was also Neyantahu’s opening salvo against President-elect Joe Biden in what is already set to be an uneasy relationship. Rather than endearing himself and Israel to the new American president, Bibi instead chose to throw the first punch. This is astonishing, even for Netanyahu’s standards. His signal to Biden was clear: On Iran policy, I call the shots.
I write about this for Newsweek today.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is not one to pull his punches when it comes to American presidents. The assassination of Iranian nuclear scientist Mohsen Fakhrizadeh was not just a particularly daring attack against Iran. It was also Neyantahu’s opening salvo against President-elect Joe Biden in what is already set to be an uneasy relationship. Rather than endearing himself and Israel to the new American president, Bibi instead chose to throw the first punch. His signal to Biden was clear: On Iran policy, Israel calls the shots.
Netanyahu has famously poor relations with Democratic Presidents. His bullying personality and lack of deference to the United States left an aghast Bill Clinton exclaiming “Who’s the fucking superpower here?” after their first meeting.
His relationship with Barack Obama was even worse. Their first official meeting at the White House in May 2009 was, by all accounts, a disaster—and it went downhill from thereon. But unlike Netanyahu’s approach to Biden today, neither Obama nor Netanyahu actually wanted their relationship to turn sour. The breakdown was not caused on purpose, but rather through a series of misunderstandings and misperceptions.
While Netanyahu knew that Obama was likely to request limitations on settlement building, he did not expect Obama to request a “complete settlement freeze,” as soon as possible. Netanyahu felt ambushed, telling his aides afterward that he felt “punched in the nose.” The Obama team, meanwhile, believed that the request on settlements had been well telegraphed in the weeks preceding the meeting.
Not one to turn the other cheek or give Obama the benefit of the doubt, Netanyahu quickly returned the favor. During the joint press conference after their meeting, Obama focused on the need for progress on the Israeli-Palestinian issue (which never appeared to be a matter of urgency for Netanyahu, to put it mildly,) and for diplomacy with Iran (which Bibi opposed outright.)
Seeking to create an atmosphere conducive to diplomacy, Obama had deliberately toned down the rhetoric on Iran in hope of convincing a highly suspicious Tehran of his sincerity. He had, for instance, completely avoided threatening language, including George W. Bush‘s favorite phrase—”all options remain on the table”—precisely because he knew his chances of getting the Iranians to come to the table would dwindle if he appeared to be threatening them.
Netanyahu also understood the logic perfectly well. So to sabotage Obama, he turned to the American president and told the reporters:
“I very much appreciate, Mr. President, your firm commitment to ensure that Iran does not develop nuclear military capability, and also your statement that you’re leaving all options on the table.”
Obama, had, of course said no such thing in public. Netanyahu put the words in his mouth, knowing very well how the paranoid decision-makers in Tehran would interpret it. No other friend of the United States treats American Presidents this way.
With Biden, Netanyahu has chosen to avoid any misunderstandings: He’s throwing the first punch even before the former Vice President has had the chance to take the oath of office. Bibi had already publicly forbidden the U.S. to rejoin the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA)—”There can be no going back to the previous nuclear agreement,” he said last month—and with the assassination, he signaled Biden that he won’t hesitate to aggressively undermine the American president if Biden chooses to pursue the path he believes best serves America’s interests.
This is astonishing, even for Netanyahu’s standards. After all, Israel needs the United States far more than the U.S. needs Israel. But decades of American deference to Israel and other partners in the Middle East have emboldened them to not only challenge U.S. presidents but also undermine them. Deference has bred recklessness and disregard for U.S. interests. Not surprisingly, this has left Netanyahu with a perception of impunity.
Biden must now decide whether to correct Netanyahu’s perception or adjust to it. Some in Biden’s circle have at least in the past advised that more deference to Israel could have tempered Netanyahu’s opposition to the Iran deal (it is unclear as to whether they still hold those views after the Fakhrizadeh assassination.)
Others, like Obama’s deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes, believe Netanyahu is categorically opposed to any deal with Tehran—no amount of deference or consultation can change that. Last week, Rhodes issued an impassioned plea to the Biden team not to fall into trap of thinking that Netanyahu can be brought over to the pro-diplomacy camp:
“I plead with [the Biden team],” Rhodes said on Pod Save World. “Do not think there is any ounce of good faith that will be coming your way from Bibi Netanyahu, from MBS, and from the Tom Cottons of this world. They will convince you that they are really for a better deal. That they just want to help you get a better deal… That is a heaping pile of bullshit. These people have no interest in a deal. They’ve never had an interest in a deal. How many times do we have to go through this play? This is in the hands of the Biden people to say: We don’t need to listen to these people.”
Rhodes speaks from bitter and direct experience. The Obama administration consulted extensively with the Netanyahu government during the course of the JCPOA negotiations and only stopped sharing intel with the Israelis once US intelligence picked up that the Israeli ambassador to Washington selectively leaked information in order to undermine the talks.
Netanyahu didn’t do this only to Obama; he even conspired with John Bolton to prevent Donald Trump from meeting with Iranian foreign minister Javad Zarif, revealing that he was not opposed to Obama’s nuclear deal because of its alleged flaws but rather opposed to any deal with Iran. After all, in Trump, Netanyahu had a president willing to break with all his predecessors in acquiescing to almost all key Israeli demands. Yet, even with such a deferential President, Netanyahu opposed the U.S. even talking to Iran, let alone striking a deal with it.
Biden now has a choice to make. Either he allows Netanyahu to define his options in the Middle East—which, given how things are going, would mean that America would have to prepare for some form of a confrontation with Iran sooner rather than later. Or he charts out a new approach for America in the Middle East, with new parameters and benchmarks for success that do not all hinge simply on pleasing Netanyahu.
On Tehran, this would likely entail Biden seeking to put the entire US-Iran relationship on a new footing, in order to better protect US interest, as well as protect the nuclear deal from efforts by Israel, Saudi or the UAE to kill the nuclear deal.
On Israel, Biden is faced with an unequivocal reality, now more starkly defined than during his previous term in high office. Either America returns to an already charted diplomatic path that makes Iran part of the solution instead of the problem, stabilizes the region and ultimately makes even Israel itself more secure; or it sacrifices its own interests for the insurmountable anxieties of one prime minister (and two authoritarian rulers in the Persian Gulf)—which, if indulged, would ironically lead to confrontation, or to war.
Obama left the White House still believing that a middle ground between charting a new path on the Middle East and appeasing Israel existed. Netanyahu is going over and above to make it plain to Biden at the outset that he won’t allow for any middle paths. Whether Biden likes or not, he will have to decide on who calls the shots on America’s Iran policy—the President of the United States or the Prime Minister of Israel.
Trita Parsi is the Executive Vice President of the Quincy Institute and author of Losing an Enemy – Obama, Iran, and the Triumph of Diplomacy.
We See The World From All Sides and Want YOU To Be Fully InformedIn fact, intentional disinformation is a disgraceful scourge in media today. So to assuage any possible errant incorrect information posted herein, we strongly encourage you to seek corroboration from other non-VT sources before forming educated opinion. In addition, to get a clear comprehension of VT's independent non-censored media, please read our Policies and Disclosures.
Due to the nature of uncensored content posted by VT's fully independent international writers, VT cannot guarantee absolute validity. All content is owned by the author exclusively. Expressed opinions are NOT necessarily the views of VT, other authors, affiliates, advertisers, sponsors, partners, or technicians. Some content may be satirical in nature. All images are the full responsibility of the article author and NOT VT. About VT - Comment Policy
Bibi Demands That You Kneel:
Here is an Example:
This is what Bibi Netanyahu said while sitting at the head of that private table in Fink’s Bar (transcribed from a secretly recorded audio of Netanyahu at that meeting – words that few Americans, Israelis or others have seen or heard until today):
“If we get caught, they will just replace us with persons of the same cloth. So, it does not matter what you do. America is a golden calf; and we will suck it dry, chop it up, and sell it off piece by piece until there is nothing left but the world’s biggest welfare state that we will create and control. Why? Because it is the will of God, and America is big enough to take the hit; so, we can do it again and again and again. This is what we do to countries that we hate. We destroy them very slowly and make them suffer for refusing to be our slaves.” [Confirmed by an “attendee” during a debriefing.]
Why does everyone keep on pushing this same monotnous roundabout of perpetual lies and meaninless deception. Netanyahu, Biden, Trump….they’re all paid up members of the same satanic cabal. Voting in America is just a quadrennial ritual for the sheeple, the followers of Lucifer decide the victor and the chosen winner is the most pliable sycophant, capable of fufilling their psychopathic designs for mankind. It matters not one iota who carries the breastpin of “President”, they’ll carry out the preplanned agenda as instructed….until the next circus begins in four yers time !
It’s not so much BiBi one need’s to be worried about, it’s The City of London as Rothschild says he own’s 60%. BiBi is essentially Rothschild’s yappy little lapdog.
Biden is expendable, and so is Harris, if either gets too out of line.
Biden is absolutely a rabid Zionist, and will undoubtedly follow Zionist Khazar criminal Banking Cabal direction.
You mean over and above what Trump has been doing ? Gee I can’t imagine what that could be …
If Biden is such a rabid Zionist then why is Bibi and the trashy Israeli firster republicans ate ripping themselves new ones to cancel the election results ?
Your argument is a populist fallacy that is used to paint everybody as corrupt and incompetent, so as to justify Trump lies/crimes.
To Jared Kushner the director of the Office of American Innovation .. lol.
You guys are laughable.
Comments are closed.