Nathan Cofnas’ appeal to biological and social evolution to explain away the objectivity of morality is counterproductive precisely because Cofnas obviously believes that there is such a thing called anti-Semitism.

Whether Taylor and others like it or not, they are the intellectual children of Charles Darwin, which is to say they are bound to live in intellectual contradiction for the rest of their natural lives.

. MacDonald hasn’t dealt into the issue very much, but he is making what seems to be authoritative statement about the same issue—statements like “it is not that important.” As I have argued in my recent book Kevin MacDonald’s Metaphysical Failure: A Philosophical, Historical, and Moral Critique of Evolutionary Psychology, Sociobiology, and Identity Politics, there is more to MacDonald’s ideological foundation and intellectual inconsistency than meets the eye.

In order to say that ‘logic and reason prove nothing,’ one obviously has to use logic and reason–an impressively and fantastically incoherent argument.